Page 1 of 1

Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 07 Jan 2008, 09:30
by somebody
Hello.

I sent a mail to one of my accounts "herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty@trashmail.net". When I received that mail, I noticed that the Reply-To: header is set to something like "herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty.reply.alexander_skwar_at_example_net@trashmail.net" (instead of example_net, the real sender domain was mentioned). I then replied to this mail, ie. I sent a mail to herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty.reply.alexander_skwar_at_example_net@trashmail.net and received that mail just fine at my "examle.net" account. From: in the reply was set to the original From of the account from which I send the mail.

Why is the Reply-To: header set? Why do you "force" users to relay mails over trashmail.net?

Best regards,
Alexander

Re: Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 07 Jan 2008, 22:57
by Admin
somebody wrote:Hello.

I sent a mail to one of my accounts "herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty@trashmail.net". When I received that mail, I noticed that the Reply-To: header is set to something like "herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty.reply.alexander_skwar_at_example_net@trashmail.net" (instead of example_net, the real sender domain was mentioned). I then replied to this mail, ie. I sent a mail to herausforderung-antwortfox_dcccty.reply.alexander_skwar_at_example_net@trashmail.net and received that mail just fine at my "examle.net" account. From: in the reply was set to the original From of the account from which I send the mail.

Why is the Reply-To: header set? Why do you "force" users to relay mails over trashmail.net?

Best regards,
Alexander
Hi,
its to protect your privacy.
When you use the Reply-To address, then your real email address will be replaced by the trashmail.net email address in the response.

Re: Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 24 Jul 2008, 21:21
by archermoo
How long does it take for replies to start working? I just set up a trashmail address, and have tested it twice. I received both incoming messages, but neither reply has been delivered yet.

Re: Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 28 Jul 2008, 21:44
by Admin
archermoo wrote:How long does it take for replies to start working? I just set up a trashmail address, and have tested it twice. I received both incoming messages, but neither reply has been delivered yet.
Very strange.
Please send me to support@trashmail.net the reply address.

Re: Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 31 Oct 2008, 10:22
by jobie
Thanks for this service. I just registered for Plus.
I have a similar question to that above:
Just testing to see how things work, I sent an email (1) from HM@hotmail.com to TM@rcpt.at which went to my Gmail account

The replyto address was TM.reply.HM_at_hotmail_com
I sent a reply (2) using this replyto from my Gmail and it made it to my hotmail with the From field as follows:
From: TM.reply.HM_at_hotmail_com (TM.reply.HM_at_hotmail_com@trashmail.net)

However, replying back (3) to this message from the Hotmail was not deliverable and came back from Mail Delivery System (MAILER-DAEMON@trashmail.net)

I realize that by sending the first reply through trashmail it protects my Gmail account, but because of this there cannot be several replies back and forth?
Is this how it is supposed to be?
Could the responses from our protected accounts (in this case Gmail) go through trashmail but still end up with the original Trashmail address as the From Address (in this case TM@rcpt.at)
I hope my question is clear.
And thanks again for setting this all up
j

Re: Why is "Reply-To" set?

Posted: 31 Oct 2008, 21:14
by Admin
jobie wrote: I realize that by sending the first reply through trashmail it protects my Gmail account, but because of this there cannot be several replies back and forth?
Normally yes. But what could be possible is that when your trashmail address will be automatically deleted, also the reply-to addresses will be deleted. Maybe when you tested the reply-to function you set to do only one forwarding on the trashmail address and then the address has been automatically deleted?
jobie wrote: Is this how it is supposed to be?
Yes, reply-to addresses are to protect your privacy and should work in both directions as long the trashmail address exists.
jobie wrote: Could the responses from our protected accounts (in this case Gmail) go through trashmail but still end up with the original Trashmail address as the From Address (in this case TM@rcpt.at)
Normally when you sent an email to:
TM.reply.foo_at_bar_com@trashmail.net
it means that your email will be forwarded to foo@bar.com but the receiver will see in its From header TM@trashmail.net to protect your real email address.
But I admit that maybe there is somewhere a bug in the trashmail software. :D
In this case I need to repair it.
jobie wrote: I hope my question is clear.
And thanks again for setting this all up
No problem. It you find out how to produce this MAILER-DAEMON error I would be interessted. Please post here the complete MAILER-DAEMON message (by deleteing your real email addresses). Then I could debug what is happenning.